So you’re thinking about recreating some content, or more specifically, article spinning. Your purpose here is to get more content on your blog. Before you do this, I want you to consider carefully the cons of article spinning.
What is Article Spinning?
Article Spinning is a search engine optimization technique in which website owners or bloggers attempt to manipulate their rankings in the serps (search engine results pages.) This is done by taking original content and replacing sections of the text with synonyms or reorganizing the existing structure of the article.
How Does One Spin Articles?
There are two techniques commonly used in article spinning. Manual and automatic. Manual simply means a website owner can pay someone to rewrite their article or they can do so themselves. The flip side is article spinning software which allows someone to enter an article and out comes several different articles. The spun articles will utilize synonyms to make the article seem “new.” For example, I am sad will now become, I am depressed or I am down. Doesn’t seem all that fresh to the reader, but it might to the search engines.
So, What’s the Problem?
It actually is a big problem. Most of the articles are stolen from the original author without their knowledge, let alone their consent. Placing this content on your own site is considered plagiarism. Don’t they expel students for that these days? So why on earth would you want to conduct business in this way now? I also am pretty sure most of you have heard of copyright infringement. The basic premise is that you can not claim someones work, whole or in part, and use for yourself without their consent.
The Cons
I, personally don’t see the pros in article spinning. Therefore, I am giving you the cons. Here are just a few.
- Morality. It is morally wrong to steal…and that means content too. You can spin and spin and spin, but it won’t change the fact that it is someone else’s hard work.
- Legally. There is no in between here. Stealing is illegal. Stealing content is copyright infringement and it’s against the law in most countries. I don’t think much of an explanation is needed here.
- Education. Switching the order of paragraphs or blocks of material to disguise the source obliterates the logical flow of an article. Computers can’t produce good articles. Using synonyms oft times changes the whole meaning of a sentence. If you have read a spun article, many times it makes no sense at all.
- Visitors. If you have ever done a search on Google, you will see mounds of information..repeated. Useless junk cluttering the web. People are trying to educate themselves and learn. How infuriating it is to click on five sites that all share pretty much the exact same content. What happened to diversity? To unique content?
Article Spinning: Final Thoughts
I won’t pretend that you have probably read many posts on article spinning and I am not sharing earth shattering news to you. However, what makes this post completely different from anyone else, is that it’s MY opinion. It’s my theory on the subject and that makes it unique. This is what we as blog owners must strive to achieve. Obviously we are going to discuss the same topics from time to time, but HOW we present it is the key. When writing your posts, incorporate your opinion and your experiences to give the readers a fresh new outlook.
It’s like the movies…how many movies have been made about, “boy meets girl, boy loses girl, etc..?” A million! But each one is presented to us in a different manner. Each one utilizes the writers’, directors’ and producers’ own vision of the theme. And we buy the tickets, we rent the movies and we talk at the water cooler about them.
So, if you were considering article spinning, I hope that you may reconsider now. It insults your readers intelligence. You are above that tactic. Formulate the ideas for your post and figure out your take on the topic. Then write what you know. Write about what you do, what you have tried and even what has not worked for you. I would much rather read about this then some half baked version of an article I already read somewhere else.
Image: healingdream / FreeDigitalPhotos.net Editors note: This guest post on Article Spinning was contributed to info carnivore by Lisa Drubec, I hope you'll take the time to follow her on twitter!
36 comments
SERPD says:
Nov 27, 2010
Article Spinning: The Cons, do you steal content?…
So youโre thinking about recreating some content, or more specifically, article spinning. Your purpose here is to get more content on your blog. Before you do this, I want you to consider careful……
DO FOLLOW LUV says:
Nov 27, 2010
Article Spinning: The Cons, do you steal content?…
So youโre thinking about recreating some content, or more specifically, article spinning. Your purpose here is to get more content on your blog. Before you do this, I want you to consider careful……
Barbara Ling, Virtual Coach says:
Nov 28, 2010
I’m ‘way jaded, so I don’t do the article/portal stuff anymore. You bring up good points that spinners should definitely read.
Lisa says:
Nov 28, 2010
barbara:
I completely understand the jaded feeling!! Thanks for visiting!
Dana says:
Nov 28, 2010
However, The article spinning is the fastest way to fill a blog with many article..
Lisa says:
Nov 28, 2010
Dana:
i agree it’s fast, but is it a quality way to go? When I first started out, I tried it and most of the articles were incomprehensible after spnning…of course it could have been user error!! ๐
Tweets that mention Article Spinning Cons, do you steal? | Info Carnivore -- Topsy.com says:
Nov 28, 2010
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by John Soares, Daniel Snyder. Daniel Snyder said: Article Spinning: the cons. Do you steal content? http://bit.ly/e49SSw via @XAffiliateX […]
Walls Blank says:
Nov 28, 2010
Finally someone who gets it. But most people are selfish bastards with short term sights. Grrr. I wish the clutter would disappear. Ahh! *Rambo scream
Good article!
Gabriele Maidecchi says:
Nov 28, 2010
I didn’t know about “article spinning”, but it sounds the lamest thing to do ever.
You can be sure I won’t even touch it with a stick.
Lisa says:
Nov 28, 2010
Gabriele:
good for you!! I honestly think if you can find your own voice it’s 100% better!
Daniel Sharkov says:
Nov 28, 2010
Using article spinning techniques is undoubtedly the worst thing you can do for your blog. You can get yourself a lot of trouble with that approach. For instance your site might get penalized for duplicate content by the search engines, unless you have made it 100% unique. Overall not a good idea. On the other hand spinning your own articles to upload on sites like Ezine seems like an effective way to get more backlinks. Haven’t implemented it myself, but I have read some articles on the subject and it seems to work.
Lisa says:
Nov 28, 2010
I do agree with you Daniel about ezine articles. However, I did have one article rejected there due to the fact it closely resembled a previous submission I made. There are so many different points of view on the subject, I guess it’s a personal choice!
Lisa says:
Nov 28, 2010
Daniel:
Thanks again for the opportunity to guest post here on your virtual home!
Daniel Snyder says:
Nov 29, 2010
You’re welcome, it’s always nice to host quality content from other writers! Looking forward to more in the future. ๐
Richard says:
Nov 28, 2010
Article spinning in general creates poor content. You can tell when someone uses automated software and does the synonym technique. The article looks like it was poorly translated from a different language. Frankly, I think it’s a good way to kill your own blog as readers will quickly leave and unsubscribe.
The second technique of completely re-writing an article at least creates higher quality material. However, you should differentiate between someone who takes a single article and rewrites it without adding any original thought and someone else who may use an article or multiple articles as research, but creates original content based on the research.
I’m not sure either is technically plagiarism, but the first method definitely seems unethical.
Lisa says:
Nov 30, 2010
excellent points Richard!
Soph@wordpress tutorial 2010 says:
Nov 29, 2010
We are living on the internet world, evethough it is claimed as “not good”, everyone is doing it.
Daniel Snyder says:
Nov 29, 2010
What!?! What kind of statement is that? Everyone is doing it. No clearly they are not, look at the comment thread there is plenty of people OPPOSED to spinning articles.
Lisa says:
Nov 30, 2010
I don’t think “everyone” is doing it. Remember the line our mother’s always gave us, “oh, so if so and so jumped off a bridge, would you follow?” LOL….I think it’s important that we all find our own voice out here in the blogosphere!
Article Spinner Man says:
Nov 30, 2010
Article Spinning doesn’t necessarily mean stealing. You can spin an article you wrote yourself for example. Spinners are useful tool beyond the immoral ideas mentioned in this post.
Is Article Spinning Illegal? | Hot Article Spinner Blog says:
Nov 30, 2010
[…] am inspired to make this post having seen a post over at Infocarnivore.com about “Article Spinning: Do You Steal?“. I disagree strongly with the sentiment in this article, and the opinion there is too biased […]
Lisa says:
Nov 30, 2010
I agree with you on that point ASM, I guess I was speaking more about the people who don’t even write their own articles. I still think that if someone can take the time to spin, then edit to make sure it all makes sense, that could be time well spent creating a whole new article. I know there are pros and cons of the issue and I can only say that from my own experience, it hasn’t been such a great thing.
Jeevanjacobjohn says:
Nov 30, 2010
This is really the first time I am hearing about Article spinning. Although I have heard and seen of people stealing other’s content. I do agree with you. I think bloggers should work on creating unique content. Nowadays, I see a lot of bloggers blogging about the same thing (One thing I don’t understand is that they get 20+ comments even though the content has been written a thousand time – I hate reading those blogs with same old content). Anyway, Thanks for the article.
David Leonhardt says:
Dec 2, 2010
Stealing is bad, therefore article spinning is bad. That is a puzzling conclusion. We spin all the time in life. Consider our meat. We spin beef into hamburgers, meat loaf, nachos, stew, etc. There is nothing wrong with that. We buy the meat – we spin it.
If we stole the meat from our neighbour’s house, then it would be wrong to spin it into a meatloaf or a stew. Personally, I prefer to buy my own meat before making hamburgers, and as far as I know, so do all my friends. But almost everybody I know spins their beef into various dishes – and there is nothing wrong with that because they don`t steal it. I could not imagine their reaction if I was to even bring up the topic.
I see people spinning articles all around me. Maybe not “everyone” is doing it, but lots of people are. I have yet to hear of anybody stealing someone else’s article to spin it. I certainly have heard of people paying a next to nothing for a piece of cr*p they call an “article” and spinning it – but that’s stupid, not unethical.
To me, the key point of this article is that stealing is wrong. But that is wrong whether spinning is involved or not.
Ironically, the post of mine that pops up here through CommentLuv is my post on how to spin like a pro.
Daniel Snyder says:
Dec 2, 2010
David, thanks for your thoughts! (And for taking the time to leave this comment a second time!) ๐ … I really like the analogy you present, and I do see value in spinning in the way that you are talking (re: backlinks etc…) I know that blog articles are stolen and spun all the time (I’ve even found some of mine slightly mangled in the outer reaches of the web) Off to check out your post now.
Rick LaPoint says:
Dec 3, 2010
I’m staying out of it this time, lol
Rick
What blogging IS NOT. Examples: Not a Blog. | Info Carnivore says:
Dec 8, 2010
[…] In one way I do understand the desire of so many to publish something and then have visits, traffic, clicks, comments etc.รย But these type of blogs are not flourishing, for the most part they are filling the web with duplicate content, they are not as offensive as splogs but they may as well be.รย To be blunt, I must say that if you can’t write original content and actually post something that will have value to readers and groups of people other than your immediate family and friends than blogging may not be for you.รย Okay here’s an admission of my own guilt, when I first started blogging I posted some articles that I’d grabbed from other sites (shoot me now!), not because I was intending on stealing content, but because I truly didn’t understand blogging, and I thought that really was a common practice, oops!รย Well it may be common, but it’s not right.รย If the topic of stealing content piques your interest you may also be interested in reading a recent guest post here about article spinning. […]
Doc Sheldon says:
Dec 30, 2010
Great post, Lisa! I agree with you 99%. The only thing I take exception to is your statement that article spinning is a search engine optimization technique. I’ve been a copywriter for many years, and an SEO for nearly five years, and I certainly believe that spinning is morally and legally wrong.
However, I don’t think it can be fairly called an SEO technique. That’s like saying that hacking is an IT technique.
More aptly put, it’s an underhanded way of avoiding the sometimes mundane tasks of SEO.
Daniel Snyder says:
Jan 3, 2011
Hey Doc! Thanks for your comment. I agree with what you’re saying in some regards, however I also understand how people think spinning helps their SEO… but you’re right the two are loosely attached and not directly related.
ryanogs says:
Jan 4, 2011
I disagree with you to a certain extent here, if you are using old content then fine, its wrong.
On the other hand, if you are writing the content from scratch and are taking the time to manually rewrite the setentences properly when spinning then how is this a bad technique to use?
It is neither illegal, morally wrong or damaging to blogs.
Rob Falla says:
Jan 29, 2011
I agree.
Generally I write a long article or white paper to start. From that I create several shorter articles to be used for blog postings and pushed out through other channels. This is both legitimate spinning of my own content and a valuable SEO technique.
Many thanks,
Rob
Daniel Snyder says:
Jan 31, 2011
I like what your suggesting Rob. I agree, I often have lengthy posts that I write – and splitting them up and publishing over a few days, gives me more material with which to work with and promote. Smart man! ๐ thanks for your visit.
KeyCAPTCHA says:
Apr 25, 2011
This article says that the article spinning is bad.
But what can be done to reclaim infriged author rights.
The problem is not in stealing but that the search through Google.com by my company name (and it is the same as online service) gives only results to spam using its name in their content
Post-Panda, Your Original Content is Being Outranked by Scrapers & Partners
http://www.seomoz.org/blog/postpanda-your-original-content-is-being-outranked-by-scrapers-amp-partners
Nonoy says:
Feb 27, 2012
Very useful thoughts you shared here. I’ve just learned this technique from an outsurcing company I’m working for. I completely hated the idea due to the same reasons you mentioned in your post.
I don’t know if I can continue spinning articles while sticking on what I believe. I can’t change what the company practices though. ๐
daniel says:
Mar 9, 2012
http://www.articlespinner.in works best when it comes to automated rewriting of articles.
not totally free though,.
William says:
Mar 10, 2012
I have used The Best Spinner, Spin Robot and Spin Rewriter. Of all of these programs I find myself using Spin Rewriter the most, due to its simplicity, online interface and efficiency. It’s just quick and easy, plus it updates its interface more often than either of the other two programs. The real power of Spin Rewriter is that the developers respond quickly to user feedback and improve the program based on feedback.